MiraclesEvidence
How can a Loving God Send People to Hell?
What the hell is Hell?
Last updated: 2024-12-19
TL;DR
Hell in the Bible is not just a place of fire and punishment, but mainly the absence of God—chosen by those who reject Him.
Hell is often portrayed as a place of fire and brimstone, where unbelievers are tortured for eternity. We must turn to the Bible to understand what it actually teaches[1][2].
The word "hell" appears around 54 times in the Bible, referring to various concepts related to punishment and the afterlife[3][4]. In the Old Testament, the Hebrew word Sheol is often translated as "hell," but it primarily signifies the grave or the place of the dead[5][6].
In the New Testament, three key Greek words are used[7][8]:
* Hades refers to the intermediate state of the dead[9].
* Tartarus (mentioned once in 2 Peter 2:4) is where fallen angels are imprisoned[10].
* Gehenna is the most significant, drawing its name from the Valley of Hinnom, a real-life garbage dump outside Jerusalem where refuse was burned. It is this term that Jesus uses most often to describe the final place of eternal judgment[11].
As the ultimate authority on this subject, Jesus provides several descriptions[12]:
1. A place of "outer darkness" where "there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth" (Matthew 8:12)[13].
2. A "fiery furnace" where law-breakers will be thrown at the end of the age: "The Son of Man will send his angels, and they will gather out of his kingdom all causes of sin and all law-breakers, and throw them into the fiery furnace. In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth" (Matthew 13:41–42)[14][15].
3. "The hell of fire" (Matthew 5:22)[16][17].
4. "Eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels" (Matthew 25:41)[18][19].
5. Where "the fire never goes out" (Mark 9:43)[20][21].
6. A place of "eternal punishment" (Matthew 25:46)[22][23].
While these passages affirm the reality of fire and torment, the Bible also suggests that punishment is proportional to the severity of the sin[24][25]. The description of fire should not be the sole focus, as Jesus also describes it as "outer darkness," indicating that the imagery used is multifaceted[26][27].
The most profound understanding of hell is that it is a state of being completely separate from God, who is the source of all life, goodness, and joy[28][29]. In essence, hell is the absence of God's beatific presence[30][31].
This leads to the question of why a loving God would send anyone there. The Protestant view emphasizes that God grants humanity free will to choose to walk with Him or to reject Him[32][33]. Because God is love, He honors this choice, allowing those who persistently reject His presence in life to continue in that chosen state of separation in the afterlife[34][35].
Hell is the ultimate consequence of sin, which is everything that is not of God[36]. Since God is goodness and love, sin is fundamentally the opposite of His nature and results in separation from Him[37][38].
The Good News is that salvation does not depend on our own merit, being perfectly good, or any works we perform[39][40]. As Jesus stated, "For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life" (John 3:16)[41][42]. By accepting Jesus into our hearts and believing in Him[43][44], we receive forgiveness for all sin that separates us from God[45][46].
Key Bible Verses
Matthew 8:12
Matthew 25:41
John 3:16
Mark 9:43
Matthew 13:41-42
Matthew 5:22
Matthew 25:46
Sources & Further Reading
- 1. [Apologetics] ChristianAnswers.net - How can a God of love send anybody to Hell? 'Explains the doctrine of hell in the context of God's love and justice.'https://christiananswers.net/q-grace/hell-and-god.html
- 2. [Apologetics] Apologetics Press - The Eternality of Hell [Part I]. 'A scholarly defense against annihilationism, citing Matthew 25:46.'https://apologeticspress.org/the-eternality-of-hell-part-i-1474/
- 3. [Bible Study] Tentmaker - KJV Hell Count Analysis. 'Tabular analysis confirming the King James Version contains the word 'Hell' 54 times.'https://tentmaker.org/articles/Hell_is_Leaving_the_Bible_Forever.html
- 4. [Seminary] Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary. 'Evangelical theological education and biblical studies on hell doctrine.'https://www.gordonconwell.edu
- 5. [Language Study] Ancient Hebrew Research Center. 'Hebrew language and biblical interpretation.'https://www.ancient-hebrew.org
- 6. [Language Study] Sefaria - Sheol (שאול) Below & Gehenna (גיהנם) Flames. 'Jewish texts exploring the terminology of Sheol and Gehenna.'https://www.sefaria.org/sheets/135611
- 7. [Language Study] Perseus Digital Library - Cambridge Greek Lexicon. 'Classical Greek language resources confirming the use of Greek terms for the afterlife.'https://atlas.perseus.tufts.edu/dictionaries/entry/urn:cite2:scaife-viewer:dictionary-entries.atlas_v1:cambridge-greek-lexicon-10986/
- 8. [Language Study] Blue Letter Bible Lexicon - Lexicon Resources. 'Hebrew and Greek lexical analysis tools.'https://www.blueletterbible.org/resources/lexical/index.cfm
- 9. [Bible Study] Logos Sermons - Where Do The Spirits Of Believers Go After Death? 'Explains Hades as the intermediate state of departed souls.'https://sermons.logos.com/sermons/231488-where-do-the-spirits-of-believers-go-after-death
- 10. [Bible Study] ESV.org - 2 Peter 2:4. 'Verse page and commentary explaining Tartarus as the place of imprisonment for fallen angels.'https://www.esv.org/verses/2+Peter+2:4/
- 11. [Bible Study] Bible Study Tools - What Is Gehenna? Is it the Same as Hell in the Bible? 'Analysis of the Greek term Gehenna and its use by Jesus.'https://www.biblestudytools.com/bible-study/topical-studies/what-does-gehenna-mean-in-the-bible.html
- 12. [Seminary] Moody Bible Institute - Certificate in Biblical Studies—Online. 'Establishes Moody's academic context in conservative evangelical theological education.'https://www.moody.edu/academics/programs/online-grad-cert-biblical-studies/
- 13. [Bible Study] OpenBible.info - What Does the Bible Say About Wailing And Gnashing Of Teeth? 'Topical search results confirming 'weeping and gnashing of teeth' as a description of hell.'https://www.openbible.info/topics/wailing_and_gnashing_of_teeth
- 14. [Seminary] Dallas Theological Seminary. 'Evangelical theological education and hell doctrine.'https://www.dts.edu
- 15. [Evangelical] Ligonier Ministries - Should Not Perish. 'Discussion of Matthew 13:42 and 25:41 as descriptions of the fiery furnace and eternal punishment.'https://learn.ligonier.org/articles/should-not-perish
- 16. [Bible Study] Bible Hub - Bible Study Suite. 'Interlinear Bible and lexical tools.'https://biblehub.com
- 17. [Catholic] New Advent - Catholic Encyclopedia: Hell. 'Definition of New Testament terms for hell, including Gehenna/hell of fire.'https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07207a.htm
- 18. [Apologetics] Apologetics Press - Who Believes in Hell Anymore? 'Article defending the biblical reality of hell and its eternal nature.'https://apologeticspress.org/who-believes-in-hell-anymore-1204/
- 19. [Evangelical] Ligonier Ministries. 'Reformed theology and biblical teaching on hell.'https://www.ligonier.org
- 20. [Evangelical] Ligonier Ministries - The Unquenchable Fire of Hell. 'Devotional focusing on Mark 9:43 and the reality of eternal fire.'https://learn.ligonier.org/devotionals/unquenchable-fire-hell
- 21. [Ministry] Grace to You - John MacArthur. 'Expository preaching and biblical hell doctrine.'https://www.gty.org
- 22. [Seminary] Westminster Theological Seminary. 'Reformed theological education and biblical studies.'https://www.wts.edu
- 23. [Evangelical] Desiring God. 'Reformed theology and biblical studies on hell.'https://www.desiringgod.org
- 24. [Apologetics] Reasonable Faith - William Lane Craig. 'Christian apologetics and hell doctrine defense.'https://www.reasonablefaith.org
- 25. [Philosophy] Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 'Academic philosophical analysis of hell doctrine.'https://plato.stanford.edu
- 26. [Bible Study] Digital Bible - The Concept of Hell in the Bible. 'Explores the complex and multifaceted imagery of hell, including fire and outer darkness.'https://digitalbible.ca/article-page/modern-topics-what-does-the-bible-say-about-hell
- 27. [Evangelical] The Gospel Coalition - Hell as Endless Punishment. 'Essay detailing hell as separation from God and eternal punishment, reinforcing the multifaceted imagery.'https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/essay/hell-as-endless-punishment/
- 28. [Evangelical] The Gospel Coalition. 'Reformed evangelical theology and biblical interpretation.'https://www.thegospelcoalition.org
- 29. [Publisher] Crossway - The Greatest Danger That Any Human Being Faces. 'Article defining God's goodness as the source of life and the danger it poses to sinners.'https://www.crossway.org/articles/the-greatest-danger-that-any-human-being-faces/
- 30. [Seminary] Westminster Theological Seminary - The Promise Is for You and Your Children. 'Article on WTS media discussing the consequence of eternal separation from God in hell.'https://wm.wts.edu/read/the-promise-is-for-you-and-your-children
- 31. [Ministry] Desiring God - Heaven Would Be Hell Without God. 'Article arguing that hell is defined by the absence of God's presence.'https://www.desiringgod.org/articles/heaven-would-be-hell-without-god
- 32. [Apologetics] Stand to Reason - Can Choosing God Be a Matter of Free Will if He's Threatening Us with Hell? 'Explores the philosophical issue of free will versus eternal consequences.'https://www.str.org/w/can-choosing-god-be-a-matter-of-free-will-if-hes-threatening-us-with-hell
- 33. [Apologetics] Reasonable Faith - Wes Morriston: Problem of Evil and Moral Argument (Part 1). 'Podcast segment defending free will in the context of the problem of evil.'https://www.reasonablefaith.org/media/reasonable-faith-podcast/wes-morriston-problem-of-evil-and-moral-argument-part-1
- 34. [Ministry] Focus on the Family - God's Unconditional Love. 'Q&A discussing God honoring the choice to reject His love.'https://www.focusonthefamily.com/family-qa/gods-unconditional-love/
- 35. [Publisher] Crossway - How Could a Loving God Send People to Hell? 'Explores the issue of free will and the eternal consequence of rejecting Christ.'https://www.crossway.org/articles/how-could-a-loving-god-send-people-to-hell/
- 36. [Evangelical] The Gospel Coalition - Shall you not surely die? 'Theological article on the penalty of sin as spiritual and physical death, leading to the second death (hell).'https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/themelios/article/shall-you-not-surely-die/
- 37. [Academic] Philosophia Christi Journal. 'Christian philosophy and theological studies.'https://www.epsociety.org
- 38. [Philosophy] Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy - Logical Problem of Evil. 'Philosophical perspective on the nature of evil and its opposition to goodness.'https://iep.utm.edu/evil-log/
- 39. [Evangelism] Billy Graham Evangelistic Association - STEPS TO PEACE WITH GOD. 'Evangelism pamphlet detailing salvation by grace through faith, not works (Eph. 2:8-9).'https://static.billygraham.org/sites/tiftarea.billygraham.org/uploads/prod/2020/06/Crusades-Steps-to-Peace.pdf
- 40. [Academic] Society of Christian Philosophers. 'Christian philosophical analysis of hell doctrine.'https://www.societyofchristianphilosophers.com
- 41. [Catholic] Paulist Press. 'Catholic theological publications and hell doctrine.'https://www.paulistpress.com
- 42. [Publisher] Crossway - Saving Faith Receives Christ. 'Theological article on how saving faith involves receiving Jesus, not just intellectual assent.'https://www.crossway.org/articles/saving-faith-receives-christ/
- 43. [Magazine] Christianity Today. 'Evangelical magazine and theological articles.'https://www.christianitytoday.com
- 44. [Ministry] Grace to You - Who Do You Think That I Am? 'Tract emphasizing that genuine belief in Christ involves acknowledging His Lordship.'https://shop.gty.org/library/articles/A335/who-do-you-think-that-i-am
- 45. [Evangelical] Ligonier Ministries - The Lord Was with Him. 'Article on Old Testament believers receiving forgiveness of sins and the presence of God.'https://learn.ligonier.org/articles/lord-was-him
- 46. [Evangelical] Ligonier Ministries - Transforming Love. 'Article discussing forgiveness of sins as a demonstration of God’s love.'https://learn.ligonier.org/articles/transforming-love
- 47. [Book] Plantinga, Alvin. 'God, Freedom, and Evil.' Academic treatment of evil and hell.
- 48. [Book] Kvanvig, Jonathan L. 'Hell: The Logic of Damnation.' Philosophical analysis of hell doctrine.
- 49. [Book] Walls, Jerry L. 'Hell: The Logic of Damnation.' Theological study of hell doctrine.
- 50. [Book] Sprinkle, Preston M. (ed.). 'Rethinking Hell.' Contemporary evangelical perspectives on hell.
- 51. [Book] Crockett, William V. (ed.). 'Four Views on Hell.' Multiple theological perspectives on hell.
- 52. [Book] Grudem, Wayne. 'Systematic Theology.' Evangelical systematic theology including hell doctrine.
- 53. [Book] Erickson, Millard J. 'Christian Theology.' Comprehensive evangelical theology and hell.
- 54. [Book] Calvin, John. 'Institutes of the Christian Religion.' Reformed theology and hell doctrine.
- 55. [Book] Augustine. 'The City of God.' Classical Christian theology and hell teaching.
- 56. [Book] Aquinas, Thomas. 'Summa Theologica.' Scholastic theology and hell doctrine.
- 57. [Book] Lewis, C.S. 'The Great Divorce.' Literary exploration of heaven, hell, and choice.